Capitalism and Early Modernity in the Middle Ages: An Overview of Ideological Trends
https://doi.org/10.21603/sibscript-2025-27-3-489-505
EDN: GFJSKC
Abstract
Capitalism first emerged in the Middle Ages against the backdrop of social and cultural innovations that may change the traditional concept of the Middle Ages as a period of pure feudalism. These innovations were global in nature and reflected the mutual influence of Western and Eastern civilizations. They also manifested a certain continuity with Classical European culture and society. The article introduces the term of Early Modernity to describe these phenomena and trends. The historiographic analysis focused on foreign and domestic studies published in 1970–2024. The ideas, institutions, and practices of early modernity found their reflection in the theories of transitional society, modernization, and proto-industrialization, as well as in the studies that covered the trade revolution of XII–XIII centuries. The new temporality and space arrangement of the global Middle Ages appeared in the images of a single Afro-Eurasia and the Post-Classical Period. As the status of medieval technologies, knowledge systems, and ideas about the world increased, it yielded the concept of global technological and cultural rise in the XI–XIII centuries. Such expanded interpretation of the Middle Ages and genesis of capitalism caused a critical reaction from medievalists. While acknowledging the shortcomings of the standard approach to Western European feudalism, they stick to the key criteria in defining the classical Middle Ages and the feudal revolution. However, macrohistorical studies seriously consider the world-system perspective and the context of global history.
References
1. Arrighi G. The long twentieth century: Money, power and the origins of our times. Moscow: Territoriia buduchshego, 2006, 470. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/qrvokl
2. Bogaturov A. D., Vinogradov A. V. Enclave-conglomerate type of development. The experience of trans-system theory. East – West – Russia: Collection of articles. Moscow: Progress-Traditiia, 2002, 109–128. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/ttpukl
3. Bogdanov A. A short course of economics. Kharkov: Gos. izd-vo Ukrainy,1923, 240. (In Russ.)]
4. Borchardt J. Accumulation of capital. Moscow- Leningrad: Gosizdat, 1926, 336. (In Russ.)]
5. Vasiliev L. S. Problems of the genesis of the Chinese State. Moscow: Nauka, 1983, 327. (In Russ.)]
6. Vasyutin S. A. Nomads of Inner Asia of the VI – early XII century in global history. Irkutsk: Ottisk, 2020, 351. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/hubbej
7. Vinokurova M. V. What was discussed during the session on feudalism at the conference "Rethinking the Middle Ages, or audit Russian Medieval history". Srednie Veka, 2020, 81(1): 48–56. (In Russ.)] https://doi.org/10.7868/S0131878020010055
8. Volodarsky V. V., Yusim M. A., Vinokurova M. V., Bragina L. M., Nikolaeva I. Yu., Kuznetsov V. N., Zaretsky Yu. P., Dmitrieva O. V., Uvarov P. Yu. Day three. Early Modern period and the theory of modernization. Srednie Veka, 2009, 70(1-2): 98–138. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/nxcbcn
9. Gordon A. V. Modern period as a type of Civilization: Scientific and analytical review. Moscow: INION, 1996, 63. (In Russ.)]
10. Greif A. Institutions and the path to the modern economy. Lessons from Medieval trade. Moscow: HSE, 2013, 531. (In Russ.)]
11. Grinin L. E., Korotaev A. V. Social macroevolution: The genesis and transformation of the World-System. Moscow: Librokom, 2009, 568. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/rvxmlp
12. Grosul V. Ya. On the periodization of general and native history. Otechestvennaia istoriia, 2007, (3): 122–139. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/hzxlnf
13. Derlugyan G. Modernity and modernizers. Ekspert, 2010, (1): 18–24. (In Russ.)]
14. Dzhevelegov A. K. Trade in the West in the Middle Ages. St. Petersburg: Brokgaus-Efron, 1904, 223. (In Russ.)]
15. Sombart W. Modern capitalism. Vol. 2. Theory of capitalist development. Moscow: Izd. S. Skirmunta, 1904, VI+487. (In Russ.)]
16. The history of mankind. Vol. V. XVI–XVII centuries, eds. Berk P., Inalcik H. Moscow: Magistr-Press, 2004, 500. (In Russ.)]
17. Kareev N. I. The Modern history of Western Europe. Vol. I. The transition from the Middle Ages to Modern history. 3rd ed. St. Petersburg: Tip. M. M. Stasiulevicha, 1904, VI+416. (In Russ.)]
18. Kim O. V. The Baltic semi-periphery in international relations during Medieval and Modern periods. International relations and regional processes: Proc. III All-Russian Sci.-Prac. Conf. with Intern. Participation, Omsk, 19 Dec 2023. Omsk: OmSU, 2024, 35–40. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/vafjmk
19. Kim O. V. The role of traditional China at world technological progress in the Middle ages and Modern age. Historical and cultural heritage of Russia and China: Studies, preservation, and development: Proc. II Intern. Sci.-Prac. Conf., Krasnodar, 15 Jun 2022. Krasnodar: KSIC, 2023, 54–60. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/peqrue
20. Kim O. V. Economical and cultural preconditions of Early Modern in Medieval Europe. Bulletin of North-Eastern State University. History, 2020, 1(4): 28–36. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/fiycrx
21. Klyuev A. I., Metel O. V. Searching for chronological marks: The problem of transition from the Middle Ages to a Modern Time in the Soviet historiography. Srednie Veka, 2009, 81(3): 135–163. (In Russ.)] https://doi.org/10.7868/S0131878020030071
22. Kovalevskiy M. M. A brief overview of Economic Evolution and its division into periods. St. Petersburg: Tip. SPb. akts. obchsh. pech. dela E. Evdokimov, 1899, 28. (In Russ.)]
23. Kradin N. N. World-system analysis and the dynamics of Ancient and Medieval Societies. Stratum plus. Archeology and Cultural Anthropology, 2024, (6): 141–155. (In Russ.)] https://doi.org/10.55086/sp246141153
24. Kulisher I. M. The History of economic life in Western Europe. 8th ed. Moscow-Leningrad: Ogiz, 1931, vol. 1, XVI+450. (In Russ.)]
25. Lachmann R. Capitalists in spite of themselves. Elite Conflict and economic transitions in Early Modern Europe. Moscow: Territoriia buduchshego, 2010, 454. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/qpobqr
26. Poberezhnikov I. V. The spase aspects of Russian modernization. Economicheskaya istoriya, 2010, (2): 18–26. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/ncwujx
27. Poberezhnikov I. V. Protoindustrialization as a subprocess and stage of Modernization: Theoretical problems. Economic Development and the Practice of Reforms, eds. Bokarev Yu. P. et al. Moscow: IE RAS, 2015, 14–34. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/uwvvlt
28. Polanyi K. The great transformation: The political and economic origins of our time. St. Petersburg: Aleteiia, 2002, 320. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/vumqir
29. Radek K. B. The history of the revolutionary movement in China: Lectures, 1926–1927. Moscow: Sun Yat-sen University, 1927, 44. (In Russ.)]
30. Ryabova M. A. The rate of profit in the Venetian trade in the first half of the fifteenth century. Srednie Veka, 2009, 83(4): 111–141. (In Russ.)] https://doi.org/10.7868/S0131878022040055
31. Sogomonov A. Yu., Uvarov P. Yu. The discovery of the social: The paradox of the XVI century. Odysseus. Man in History, 2001, 2001: 199–215. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/qyblmf
32. Stetsyura T. D. Category of property in the scholasticism of the XIII – beginning XIV centuries. The phenomenon of property in the social structure of the Western European Middle Ages, ed. Khachaturyan N. A. St. Petersburg: Aleteiia, 2020: 380–392. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/dfplrp
33. Uvarov P. Yu. On the "clearing" of the Early Modern Age. Srednie Veka, 2009, 70(1-2): 129–138. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/thdlyp
34. Uvarov P. Yu. Feudalism on the horizon, or forty years later (part 1). Srednie Veka, 2023, 84(4): 8–28. (In Russ.)] https://doi.org/10.7868/S0131878023040013
35. Yusim M. A., Svanidze A. A., Yusim M. A., Boytsov M. A., Gorsky A. A., Korotaev A. V., Alaev L. B., Ryabinin A. L., Vasyutin S. A., Uvarov P. Yu. Day two. Discussion what are the Middle Ages? Srednie Veka, 2009, 70(1-2): 45–97. (In Russ.)] https://elibrary.ru/nxcbcd
36. Falk S. The light ages: The surprising story of Medieval science. Moscow: Alpina Publisher, 2023, 440. (In Russ.)]
37. Florèn A. The class struggle and protoindustrialization: The struggle for control over production in the iron-mining areas of Nora and Linda in Sweden in the XVI–XVIII centuries. Metallurgical plants and the peasantry: Problems of the social organization of industry in Russia and Sweden in the early industrial period, eds. Minenko N. A., Torstendal R. Ekaterinburg: UrB RAS, 1992, 3–17. (In Russ.)]
38. Fursov A. I. "The medieval machine" in Jean Gimpel’s book. Rossiskaia provintsiia, 1995, (3): 152–163. (In Russ.)]
39. Fursov A. I. European civilization and capitalism: Culture and economics in the development of society. Review. Moscow: INION, 1991, 59. (In Russ.)]
40. Yusim M. A. Who, after all, invented the Middle Ages? Srednie Veka, 2023, 84(1): 9–21. (In Russ.)] https://doi.org/10.7868/S0131878023010014
41. A companion to the Global Early Middle Ages, ed. Hermans E. Yorkshire: Arc Humanities Press, 2020, 554. https://doi.org/doi:10.2307/j.ctvz0h9cf
42. Abu-Lughod J. L. Restructuring the pre-modern world-system. Review, 1990, l3(2): 273–286. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780195067743.003.0014
43. Atlas of world history, ed. Barraclough G., Overy R. J. 5th ed. L.: Hammond, 1999, 375.
44. Axelrod A. Mercenaries: A guide to private armies and private military companies. CQ Press, 2014, 440. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781483340319
45. Baek S. H., Smerdon J., Dobrin G.-C., Naimark J., Cook E., Cook B., Seager R., Cane M. A quantitative hydroclimatic context for the European great famine of 1315–1317. EGU General Assembly, 4–8 May 2020. https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu2020-613
46. Beard J. In the wake of the plague: The Black Death and the world it made. Endeavour, 2001, 25(3): 136. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0160-9327(00)01368-5
47. Berger E., Israel G., Miller C., Parkinson B., Reeves A., Williams N. World history: Cultures, states and societies to 1500. Dahlonega: University of North Georgia Press, 2016, 488.
48. Borgolte M. Die Welten des Mittelalters. Globalgeschichte Eines Jahrtausends. München: C. H. Beck, 2022, 1102.
49. Brunner J. C. The revival of infantry tactics in the Late Middle Ages. Historical Introduction. Medieval Warfare Magazine, 2012, 2(3): 5–58.
50. Chase-Dunn C., Hall T. D. Rise and demise: Comparing world-systems. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 1997, 336.
51. Daalder H. European political tradition and processes of modernization: Groups, the individual and State. Patterns of modernity. Vol. 1. The West, ed. Eisenstadt S. N. L.: Pinter, 1987, 22–43.
52. Ferguson N. The ascent of money: The financial history of the world. N. Y.: Penguin Press, 2008, 441.
53. Frank A. G. A theoretical introduction to 5000 years of world system history. Review, 1990, 13(2): 155–248.
54. Gimpel J. The cathedral builders. N. Y.: Grove Press, 1983, XIII+282.
55. Gimpel J. The Medieval machine: Industrial revolution of the Middle Ages. N. Y.: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1976, 274.
56. Global Middle Ages. The Later Middle Ages, eds. Holmes C., Standen N. Oxford-N. Y., Athens: Oxford University Press, 2018, 441.
57. Goodman J., Aston T. H., Philpin C. H. E. The Brenner debate: Agrarian class structure and economic development in pre-industrial Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987, 339.
58. Holton R. H., Hill C. The transition from feudalism to capitalism. L.: Verso Books, 1985, 196. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-17745-5_7
59. John A. From the brink of the apocalypse: Confronting famine, plague, war and death in the Later Middle Ages. N. Y.: Routledge, 2001, XVI+304. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315881133
60. Klein G., Beusen A., Janssen P. Long-term dynamic modeling of global population and built-up area in a spatially explicit way: HYDE 3.1. The Holocene, 2010, 20(4): 565–573. https://doi.org/doi:10.1177/0959683609356587
61. Kriedte P., Medick H., Shlumbohm J. Industrialization before industrialization: Rural industry in the genesis of capitalism. Cambridge-N. Y.: Cambridge University Press, 1981, 335.
62. Laiou A. E. Byzantium and the other: Relations and exchanges. L.: Routledge, 2012, 340. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351219747
63. Lopez R. S. The commercial revolution of the Middle Ages, 950–1350. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1976, 180.
64. Marks R. B. The origins of the modern world: A global and environmental narrative from the fifteenth to the twenty-first century. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2024, 328.
65. Medick H. The transition from feudalism to capitalism: Renewal of debate. Peoples history and socialist theory, ed. Samuel R. L.: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1981, 120–129. https://doi.org/10.1111/aehr.242br10
66. Mendels F. F. Proto-industrialization: The first phase of the industrialization process. The Journal of Economic History, 1972, 32(1): 241–261. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0022050700075495
67. Morillo S., Black J., Lococo P. War in world history: Society, technology, and war from Ancient times to the present, Vol. 2 – from 1500 AD. McGraw-Hill, 2008, 330.
68. Parker G. The military revolution: Military innovation and the rise of the West, 1500–1800. 2nd ed. N. Y.: Cambridge University Press, 1996, 234.
69. Renaissance of sciences in Islamic countries: Muhammad Abdus Salam, eds. Dalafi H. R., Hassan H. A. Singapore-River Edge-New Jersey: World Scientific, 1994, 351.
70. Reyerson K. Commerce and communications. The New Cambridge Medieval History. Vol. 5. 1198–1300, ed. Abulafia D. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999, 50–70. https://doi.org/10.1017/chol9780521362894.006
71. Rostow W. W. The stages of economic growth: A non-communist manifesto. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1960, 178. https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511625824
72. Skocpol Т. Wallerstein’s world capitalist system: A theoretical and historical critique. American Journal of Sociology, 1977, 82(5):1075–1089. https://doi.org/10.1086/226431
73. Spufford P. Money and its use in Medieval Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988, 467. https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511583544
74. Stark R. The victory of reason: How christianity led to freedom, capitalism and Western success. N. Y.: Random House, 2005, 357.
75. Stearns P. N. Periodization in world history: Challenges and opportunities. 21st-Century Narratives of World History: Global and Multidisciplinary Perspectives, ed. Weller R. C. Palgrave Macmillan Cham, 2017, 83–109. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-62078-7_3
76. The Cambridge world history of violence. Vol. 2: AD 500–1500 CE, eds. Gordon M., Kaeuper R., Zurndorfer H. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2020, 722.
77. Turchin P., Hoyer D., Korotayev A., Kradin N., Nefedov S., Feinman G., Levine J., Reddish J., Cioni E., Thorpe C., Bennett J. S., Francois P., Whitehouse H. Rise of the war machines: Charting the evolution of military technologies from the Neolithic to the Industrial Revolution. PLoS ONE, 2021, 16(10). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258161
78. Turnbull S. The art of Renaissance warfare: From the fall of Constantinople to the Thirty Years War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018, 272.
79. Venice Reconsidered. History and Civilization of an Italian City – State, 1297–1797, eds. Martin J., Romano D. Baltimore (Md.): Johns Hopkins university press, 2000, 538. https://doi.org/10.3138/cjh.37.3.517
80. Wallerstein I. The modern world-system. 1: Capitalist agriculture and the origin of the European world-economy in the sixteenth century. N. Y.: Academic Press, 1974, 763. https://doi.org/10.1525/9780520948570
81. Weller C. R. 21st-century narratives of world history: Global and multidisciplinary perspectives. Palgrave Macmillan Cham, 2017, XXXIII+412. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-62078-7
82. Wiesner-Hanks M. E. What is early modern history? Medford, MA and Cambridge: Polity Press, 2021, 154.
83. Wilkinson D. O. Central civilzation. Comparative Civilizations Review, 1987, 17(17): 31–59. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190846626.013.125
Review
For citations:
Kim O.V. Capitalism and Early Modernity in the Middle Ages: An Overview of Ideological Trends. SibScript. 2025;27(3):489-505. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.21603/sibscript-2025-27-3-489-505. EDN: GFJSKC
Views:
9
Email this article 